There are many reasons why I wouldn t like this book 1 I hate feeling dumb.2 It s set in Ancient Israel, 70 C.E to be exact, and the fact that I had to ask what C.E meant being a child of B.C and A.D did not go over well Refer to 1 3 It s set in Ancient Israel and I, shamefully, have absolutely no clue what happened back then I mean besides the Last Temptation of Christ and bible stories that I kind of sort of remember 1 4 The author also wrote Practical Magic, which I have not read but I have s [...]

Never before has a book entranced me the way The Dovekeepers by Alice Hoffman has I ve literally just finished reading this book and I can t get my mind to settle down It s almost as if I ve ran a race, my adrenaline is pumping and my heart beating a mile a minute, scenes from the book keep going around and around in my head My urgent need to tell everyone about this beautifully haunting book is taking over all other thoughts, so I need to get this review out before I explode Alice Hoffman is th [...]

The Good Stuff I wish I had the words to express how wonderful this book is I will be honest if Simon and Schuster hadn t sent it to me for review, I probably wouldn t have picked it up and let me tell you that would have been a shame This book is haunting and sad but yet so full of hope and of the resilience of the human spirit Beautiful raw and honest story and just so god damned emotional to read Exceptionally real and strong female characters History written so it comes alive and you learn s [...]

The Dovekeepers on its surface sounds like it has the potential to be incredibly moving, and I had high hopes Yet I found the reading to be of an exercise in frustration and perseverance The frustration is largely the result of the book s lack of development, which might sound weird to say about a 500 page novel It is described on its cover as a story of the siege of Masada, but fans of historical fiction will be sadly disappointed the historical context is woefully underdeveloped It happens on [...]

We were no different from the doves above us We could not speak or cry, but when there was no choice we discovered we could fly It you want a reason, take this We yearned for our portion of the sky.Masada, the word summons up images, war, Romans, Zealots, slaughter, mass suicide A place of national pride for some, historical and archaeological controversy for many, a bit of Python mockery to others On visiting the place itself Alice Hoffman was inspired to wonder about the experience of the wome [...]

Alice Hoffman will teach the reader about an event which most of us know nothing about this is a factual story with fictional characters interwoven Four women who are refugees at Masada over 2000 years ago Hoffman tells their story will you listen this is where they worked a dovecote at Masadathis is where they lived the fortress at MasadaA colossal triumph Hoffman shines in this endeavour which took her five years to write Interesting Hell, yeah This story, the fact and the fiction, will linger [...]

For fans of Alice Hoffman this book is a mixture of the new and the familiar Devotees will recognize the strong women with unusual, even magical abilities What s new is the historical setting and time the fortress of Masada in the year 70 CE Also, Hoffman s language struck me as different in this book I think whether or not readers like this book will hinge on their reaction to the language Hoffman uses to recreate the world of her women I loved the level of detail I felt the sea salt in my hair [...]

Alice Hoffman brought me back in time and I enjoyed learning about what life was like in 70 C.E The writing was beautiful and at times poetic I like my poetry in short doses though and after two hundred pages of lyrical prose I was ready to move on with the story I liked the book, in fact I was swept away in the lives of the brave women it was about Revka, Aziza, Shirah and Yael were strong women who lived amazing lives and were the only survivors of the Masada massacre Unfortunately, the parts [...]

An exceptional read This is a masterpiece, a wonderful, mesmerizing book about the lives of four strong Jewish women, each with different backgrounds, powerful personalities, and distinct stories of there own Their histories collided when destiny circumstances found them living at the Jewish stronghold, Masada, during the last and final siege by the Romans According to the historian, Josephus, two of these women and five children survived the horrendous event I agree with Janet, a reviewer who s [...]

I was absolutely taken by this amazing story which was based on historical events of which I knew nothing about The writing is beautiful and the story of these strong and willful women will remain with me for a long time.

Onvan The Dovekeepers Nevisande Alice Hoffman ISBN 145161747X ISBN13 9781451617474 Dar 504 Safhe Saal e Chap 2011

2.75 Being a huge AH fan I m somewhat embarrassed with my rating and reception to this novel With only a couple of exceptions, every GR friend who read it rated it very highly Writers Toni Morrison and Wally Lamb praised it as well So what s up with me I offer up my thoughts for those very few of you who also struggled.I ended up feeling like many of the Jews wandering in the desert for forty years, except for me it was forty years of five hundred pages Initially, the chosen people were happy to [...]

This was massively underwhelming The plot was terrible it had no real development or drive In reality, it barely existed at all The story just followed the lives of some rather mundane characters There was little to keep me reading They weren t really striving for anything, beyond survival thus, I found myself getting quite bored with their stories They just weren t very remarkable The historical detail was minimal, and the random magic elements that were worked in the plot were just so pointles [...]

Dovekeepers is the first book I ve read of Alice Hoffmans In fact, one evening my wife looked at the book while I was reading in bed and said You re reading Alice Hoffman I ve read Alice Hoffman But you don t read Alice Hoffman And so I DID read Alice Hoffman and I liked Alice Hoffman This is a very good book It s real deep and very weighty Dovekeepers orbits around the real life events of the early 70s A.D in ancient Judea Rome was large and in charge and in the midst of shattering a Judean reb [...]

This is a work of historical fiction The story is based on the Roman attack on the fortress at Masada in 73 A.D and the resulting mass suicide Since I have visited this site in present day Israel, I was interested in reading a novel based on this event.In terms of the history, Hoffman has done an admirable job of researching and narrating the events at Masada She describes the time, place and culture of the ancient Hebrews with great detail.However, in terms of the fictional part of the novel, s [...]

Judea AD 70 The First Jewish Roman War In the years after the destruction of the second temple, approx 900 Jewish rebels and their families fled Jerusalem and took refuge in the fortress of Masada in the Judean desert Women Dovekeeper s collecting birds eggs, gathering droppings to ferlise the fortress s orchard s These women tending to the Masada s dovecotes, formed a small community within a larger one They each bring their conflicts with them They live with guilt, grief, loss, family conflict [...]

Once again a book I picked up because of book club One of the few books I have read in my life that made me sob like a baby at the end I ve heard they re making this into a mini series and I can t wait for it if they do I enjoyed the four stories of the women and how they meshed together An emotional ride for anyone who reads Such an outstanding work of art based on four women who come together and become family despite their backgrounds Really enjoyed

This book has been called Alice Hoffman s masterpiece, her most ambitious and mesmerizing writing, and I surely agree This is the richly told story of four strong and mysterious women from diverse paths who find themselves drawn together as sacred dovekeepers for the 900 Jews who held off the fierce Roman army for months in the Judean desert at the mountain fortress Masada No doubt you know something about the famous siege, and this great fictional yet fact related tale has all of the ancient my [...]

It s pure soap opera When the story s moving, it engages Otherwise, it s stagnant and annoying.This book has the nasty whiff of Anita Diamont phony historicity extraneous research thrown in because she has it, not because it fits names of objects e.g birthing stool that are never explained probably because the author is clueless about its use predictable outcomes of course Yael will fall in love with the enslaved legionnaire repetitive themes and phrases, ponderous and heavy handed symbols, and [...]

The only reason I would give this book 2 Stars is due to the amount of research that Alice Hoffman had obviously put into this novel, which I certainly appreciated Honestly though, I think that this roughly 500 page book could have been done in about 200 pages.Poetic descriptions saturated this novel, making for an incredibly dull read When an author spends two pages describing wind I would rather not read it I get it, it s windy It has no bearing on the plot, would you please move on with the s [...]

What an amazingly powerful novel about the fall of Jerusalem and Masada This took Hoffman five years to write and it is said to be her masterpiece, which for me it was Four women of uncommon strength of will, magic , love and their quest for survival Her writing is flawless, one feels the barrenness and the struggle for life in the dessert, their torment as they watch their family members taken from them, yet find the will to go on Trying to keep their faith in God intact and find a way to retai [...]

Wow, a lot going on here A bit repetitive and mighty superstitious, ancient times are presented here in a not too graphic presentation My first Alice Hoffman, but I have some of hers to read on my list This book has been on my TBR since 2012, so I am happy to report finishing, and well worth it.Herbane, holy plant.Burned amulets at roots offering to Ashtoresh, goddess watch in time of strife Recipe book for human heart, all we know and all experienced contained there.

Awesome read could not get enough of the storylinelove the plot twist and characters A.Hoffman is a great author paperback

I wore garments of green, white, and blue as I traversed the distance from my chamber to the chamber of Lynda, who lives in a county where rivers run not to the great inland sea where I can watch the sun rise every morning, but to the river that once formed the boundary between our land and lands of the Spanish Empire before an audacious Corsican who tried to conquer all of Europe agreed to sell them to the United States under President Thomas Jefferson Moving toward the setting of the sun, whic [...]

The desire for Jerusalem was a fire that could not be quenched There was a spark inside that holiest of holy places that made people want to possess it, and what men yearn for they often destroy.I ve realized that when I rate a book on GR, four stars mean that it s a really good book and that I would highly recommend it to most people, but when I rate a book five stars it mostly means that there was a personal connection with the book This was definitely the case with The Dovekeepers, although i [...]

Wow Fantastic Excellent Beautiful but brutal story I just finished and need to catch my breath THE DOVEKEEPERS is Alice Hoffman s most ambitious and mesmerizing novel, a tour de force of imagination and research, set in ancient Israel This book was over five years on the writing In 70 C.E nine hundred Jews held out for months against armies of Romans on Masada, a mountain in the Judean desert According to the ancient historian Josephus, two women and five children survived Based on this tragic a [...]

Every December, I trawl through the newspaper articles Best Books of the Year , noting down any titles that appeal to me I m picky, so it s usually only a few In December 2011, The Dovekeepers was one of two titles that I wrote down I m usually pleased by these choices, recommended by other authors or academics, but rarely am I transported the way that I was upon reading this magical book.Other reviewers have ably described the plotline, so I won t go into it here Suffice it to say that the nove [...]

Masada was a historic Jewish fortress that stood on huge rock in Judea now southern Israel In 73 CE 960 Jewish patriots killed themselves as Masada rather then surrender to Roman forces For many Israelis their devotion to liberty is a national symbol called the spirit of Masada This is a fictional story of four women who may have lived there.I was thoroughly entranced by this tour de force a definite masterpiece of 21st century literature This brilliant novel takes us back to Ancient Israel in t [...]

Omy goodness I don t think I ve ever read a book with such strong female characters, not just 1 but 4 , all of whom I loved and routed for Yael a young woman with red hair who is touched by a lion and has an affinity with the doves she comes to take care of Revka a bakers wife who escapes with her grandchildren after witnessing horrors so terrible that I wondered how she continued.Aziza is a warrior, the first born daughter of a woman who s wise ways and old magic will touch them all.Shirah beau [...]

Over two thousand years ago a group of approximately 900 Jewish rebels fled Jerusalem and settled in the ancient fortress called Masada Set high in the desert mountains, the fortress had been constructed for King Herod and was considered to be impenetrable In this novel, Alice Hoffman traces the paths of four fictional women whose intertwined lives become apparent when they arrive at Masada seeking refuge Hoffman weaves a tale of friendship, love, loyalty and sorrow set against the background of [...]